Argument Mapping
Purpose
Argument mapping is used to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of an argument while anticipating counterarguments and rebuttals. The Toulmin model of argument mapping, in particular, helps to break down and visually represent the components of an argument, making it easier to analyze and evaluate. The argument map itself is a diagram where you lay out claims (the proposed policy or intervention), data (evidence supporting the claim), warrants (the reasoning connecting data to claim), and any potential rebuttals or qualifiers. The process of mapping an argument helps to clearly articulate the logic behind proposed actions, identify potential weaknesses in the argument, and ensure that interventions are based on sound reasoning and evidence. By visually mapping these elements, you can clarify the logic behind a proposed intervention, identify weaknesses in the argument, and anticipate potential challenges. This helps create more robust and defensible policies and interventions by ensuring they are grounded in sound reasoning and evidence.
| Uses | Limitations |
|---|---|
|
Can refute your proposed hypothesis/conclusion (not a negative but can result in a time-consuming iteration process) |
When to Utilize
The Toulmin model of argument mapping is most useful when you need to rigorously analyze and evaluate the reasoning behind proposed policy or health-related interventions. While they can be employed independently or in groups, Argument Maps–when used collaboratively–can help ensure that a variety of perspectives are being expressed and considered, mitigating the threat of Groupthink.
The visual aspect of argument maps allows for the easy identification of incorrect assumptions as well as gaps in existing knowledge. Mapping arguments can be particularly helpful when dealing with contentious issues where there are competing arguments and a need for clear, evidence-based decision-making.
Resources
Purdue University, Toulmin Argument
Jost Wald, Argument Mapping – The Basics
Return to methods
Previous Post
Next Post