Evidence Hierarchy

Purpose

Evidence hierarchies are ranking systems that categorize available information based on the strength and rigor of the research methods that were used to generate it. The most reliable studies are placed at the top, whereas less robust designs are positioned lower down. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are frequently assigned to the highest tiers, while expert opinions and anecdotal evidence are considered lower-end information, in accordance with the varying amount of trust one can place in the findings (given the number of sources upon which the findings are based) . Like a literature review, creating an evidence hierarchy can help us to better understand the value and pitfalls of existing research. Creating evidence hierarchies can leave us better served to situate our own work in the context of existing evidence, and ensure that we are emulating and incorporating the most trustworthy available information.

Uses Limitations
  • Guide decision making
  • Better understand existing literature
  • Help design effective research studies
  • Reinforce evidence-based practices
  • Potential bias in ranking process
  • Limited availability of pre-existing studies on desired topic

When to Utilize

Creating evidence hierarchies, much like literature reviews, can be a collaborative process. Discussing the ranking of existing literature with colleagues or key stakeholders can limit the risk of bias in decision making. However, the process can also be conducted independently, and serve as a springboard for research design. Evidence hierarchies are used whenever decisions need to be based on the best available research, particularly in fields like medicine, public health, and policy. When evaluating the effectiveness of interventions, assessing risk factors, or determining the validity of research findings, evidence hierarchies help to quickly identify and prioritize studies that are most likely to provide reliable and unbiased information. They help ensure that decisions are grounded in the strongest possible evidence.

Resources

NSW Government, What is an Evidence Hierarchy, 2020

Sowdhamini Wallace, Hierarchy of Evidence Within Medical Literature, 2022



Return to methods
css.php